Poor Herbie's  |  13  Waverly Place  |  Madison, NJ 07940  | Call for Reservation:  (973) 966-0211

Facebook icon

Menu

We have a variety of Complete Entrees for your enjoyment,

served with crisp salad, crusty bread and either a baked Idaho or sweet potato, rice, mashed potatoes , vegetable, pasta, sweet or shoestring fries. Choose our famous House dressing or Thousand Island, honey mustard, oil & vinegar, or not-fat Italian.
Crumbled Bleu Cheese add $1.50

Happy Hour Menu

From 4:30pm to 6pm. Bar only

Wings $5.00

Five wings in our authentic Buffalo wing sauwce wih carrots, celery and our house bleu cheese dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Meatballs $5.00

Blue Cheese stuffed chicken meatballs with our wing sauce nd blue cheese dressing on the side.
Sampler $5.00

Three macaroni and chees triangles, three mozzarella stix, and three mini pierogies.

Kids' Menu

Franks in a Blanket $7.50
Mozzarella Stix $7.50
Grilled Cheese $7.50
Chicken Tenders/Fryz $7.50
Wings with choice of sauce $7.50
Mac 'n Cheese Triangles $7.50

Our Seasonal Appetizers

Steamed clams $8.95

18-20 count, served in a buttery clam sauce.
Shrimp Cocktail $9.95
Irish Ploughman's Platter $7.95

Thick chunks of cheddar cheese, whole grain bread, pickled red onions, pickles and a side of our Mullins mustard.
Breaded Calamari $8.25

Our Seasonal Entree Specials

Shrimp Creole $15.95

Stewed tomatoes, celery sauteed and served over linquine or rice.
Chicken Breast Parmigiana with linguine or rigatoni $18.95
Fish Special

Changes every week. Based on market price. Ask your server for details!
Bone-in Ribeye $23.95

This seasoned USDA choice cowboy steak is grilled to your liking and topped with sautéed mushrooms.

Tasty “Appe-teasers”

Guiness battered shrimp $8.95

Served with Boom Boom sauce and a Cucumber wasabi sauce. 
Soft Pretzels with Pub Cheese $8.95

Light and airy, served with our Bourbon St. Cheddar.
Stuffed Nachos $7.95

Filed with beef, pork and nacho cheese. 
Mac ’n Cheese Triangles $4.25
Chicken Fryz $6.95
“Flexible Flyers,” BBQ or Hot $7.50
Mozzarella Sticks $7.95
Den’s Hot Wings $9.75
Fried Pickles $4.25
Mini Pierogies "Your Way" $6.95
Cheddar Skins 'n Bacon $5.50

Homemade Salads & Platters

Crispy Iceberg Salad with our Famous House Dressing $5.50
Our White Tuna Salad Platter $11.95
Our Diced Chicken Breast Salad Platter $11.95
Famous Chef Salad w/ Turkey, Ham, Swiss, egg, bacon, tomatoes $14.95
Sliced Grilled Chicken Breast Salad with raw onion, bacon, tomatoes, egg $13.95
Grilled Sliced Steak Salad w/ Onion Tanglers, tomatoes $14.95

Sandwiches

Our Roast Turkey Breast & Gravy $11.95
Grilled Seasoned Chicken Breast $12.75
Our hot Roast Beef and Gravy $13.95
Classic Reuben $12.95
Our Tuna Melt $12.25
French Dip au jus $14.25
Sirloin Cheese Steak $13.95
Grilled American Cheese $7.95
Sizzlin' Hot Brooklyn Pastrami $13.25
Junior Turkey Club $11.95
Our White Tuna Salad $10.95
Our Savory Roast Beef $12.95
We-roast-it Turkey Breast $10.25
Our Diced Chicken Breast Salad $10.75

Wraps

We've taken our famous salads and turned them into wraps! Available at lunch only. 

Grilled Chicken Wrap $13.95

Chicken, lettuce, bacon, egg, tomato and onion with our  house dressing.
Grilled Steak Wrap $14.95

Steak, lettuce, onion tanglers and tomato with our house dressing.
Chef Salad $14.95

Ham, turkey, swiss cheese, egg, bacon, tomato and lettuce with our house dressing.
Diced chicken or tuna salad $11.95

Served with coleslaw, egg, and bacon.

Can’t Beat’em Burgers

Poor Herbie’s Classic $9.00
Bourbon St. Burger $11.00
Crumbled Bleu Cheese $11.00
Gluten Free Turkey Burger on Gluten Free Roll $8.50
Veggie-Burger on wheat $8.50
Burger Special

A different Burger every week. Ask your server for details and price.

Pasta Pleasures

Pasta with our chunky Homemade Marinara or smooth ‘Red’ Sauce $14.95
Pasta with Smooth Tomato Sauce $14.95
Pasta with Pink Blush Sauce $14.95
Baked Rigatoni with Mozzarella Cheese $14.95
Bleu cheese on your salad adds $1.50

Flame-Broiled On Our Grill

We have a variety of Complete Entrees for your enjoyment,

served with crisp salad, crusty bread and either a baked Idaho or sweet potato, rice, mashed potatoes , vegetable, pasta, sweet or shoestring fries. Choose our famous House dressing or Thousand Island, honey mustard, oil & vinegar, or not-fat Italian.

Crumbled Bleu Cheese add $1.50

12 oz. Center cut NY Strip Sirloin Steak, bone in $26.95
‘Poor Herbie’s’ Aged 18 oz. Ribeye ‘Club’ Steak $30.95
Rack of Lamb $23.95

7 Rib New Zealand Lamb sizzled on the grill with mint jelly.
Aged Angus 8 oz. Flatiron ‘Pub’ Steak $20.95

with sautéed onions & a cap of melted Mozzarella cheese

Savory Entrees

Roast 1/2 Chicken Golden or with our own BBQ Sauce $16.75
Our Premium Aged Steer Prime Rib au jus $29.95
Savory Pot Roast with mashed potatoes and gravy $17.95
Twin Succulent Baked Crab-Shrimp-Scallop-Cakes $18.95
Salmon Filet $18.95

Pan seared 8 oz. Scottish Salmon Filet
Our Shepherd’s Pie topped wth mashed potatoes $17.95
Crisp Half Roast Duck $18.95
Crispy Fried Chicken breast, leg, thigh and wing $16.95
Chicken Breast Francaise with lemon/butter sauce, on linguine or rice $19.95
Bangers & Mash $17.95

Traditional pork and beef Irish sausages topped with our onion stout demi-glaze. Served with peas and mashed potatoes.

Finishing Touches

Steamed Jasmine Rice* $1.95
Slivered Onion Tanglers $3.25
Today’s Steamed Veggies $2.50
Baked* or Mashed Potatoes $2.25
Hot Crusty Bread Loaf $3.25
Baked Sweet Potato* $2.95
Soup of the Day:
Cup $3.00
Bowl $5.00
Shoestring French Fries $2.75
Our Famous House Salad $5.50
w/ Crumbled Blue Cheese add $1.50
Steak-Cut Onion Rings $4.25
Sweet Potato Fries $3.95
Linguine/Rigatoni Marinara $5.95
Our Crunchy Homemade Cole Slaw $2.95

Beverages

Brewed Coffee, Regular or Decaf, with a refill $2.95
Caddy of Tea Selections: Regular, Herbal, Decaf, with a refill $2.95
Unsweetened Iced Tea, Lemonade, Fountain Sodas, with a refill $2.95
Orange, Tomato, Pineapple, Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit Juice $2.95
Mineral Water $3.95
Whole or Chocolate Milk $3.50
Hot Chocolate or Hot Cider $3.50